Home » Articles » Run & Support » Choosing Analytics for a Small SaaS: Traffic, Product Events and Session Replay

Choosing Analytics for a Small SaaS: Traffic, Product Events and Session Replay

Run & Support
Conceptual illustration of three analytics panels showing traffic bars, connected product events, and a session-replay playhead.

Choose the measurement before the tool

Documentation checked October 7, 2026: This comparison reflects the vendor sources reviewed on that date. Verify current billing terms and data controls before use.

A small SaaS team may need to answer three different questions: Where did visitors arrive from? Which product actions happened? Where did an interface appear to break down? A traffic dashboard, product-event tracking, and session replay provide different evidence. You may need one of them, a combination, or the analytics you already have. Start with a decision you will make from the result, rather than installing a three-product stack by default.

This comparison looks at Plausible and Fathom for website traffic, PostHog for product events and replay, and GA4 as an existing option to evaluate rather than automatically replace. Vendor documentation describes capabilities and billing; it does not establish which tool will perform best on your site, what your invoice will be, or what consent rules apply to your deployment.

Which question are you trying to answer?

  • Traffic: Which pages and referring sources are visible in a reporting period? Review the reporting definition and whether a visit, pageview, or custom event is the billable unit.
  • Product events: Did a defined action such as account creation or first successful use occur? Define event names, triggers, identity handling, and ownership before comparing funnels.
  • Session replay: What was rendered and interacted with during a sampled session? Replay can help investigate a usability issue, but it cannot on its own establish a person’s motivation, an error’s root cause, or an effect on conversions.

These categories overlap: traffic tools may offer custom events, and an event platform may offer traffic reports. Compare your actual questions, implementation, data handling, and usage units rather than treating the labels as exclusive product categories.

Website traffic: Plausible and Fathom

Plausible

Plausible documents website reporting and custom-event goals. Its subscription documentation counts pageviews and custom events across sites in a team toward the usage tier; the number of unique visitors is not a substitute for that billable total. Some events can be configured through its settings, WordPress integration, or Google Tag Manager; other interactions require page markup or JavaScript and verification that the goal fires as intended. Check the current subscription and usage rules and custom-event setup guide for the exact deployment.

Fathom

Fathom presents plans by monthly pageview allowance across sites, and its pricing page says pageviews and custom events share that allowance. Estimate both rather than comparing a visitor count with a pageview tier. Verify the current plan, trial, and allowance terms before budgeting; a displayed starting tier is not a universal bill for a particular site.

Both vendors describe cookie-free analytics for their standard offerings. That is a description of their products, not a determination that a whole website needs no consent mechanism or privacy notice. Other scripts, forms, identifiers, configurations, and applicable rules still need review. Plausible’s privacy documentation and Fathom’s cookie guidance describe vendor practices; Fathom explicitly says its guidance is not legal advice.

Product events: define the action before choosing PostHog

For an example signup flow, distinguish an account-created event, a first-successful-action event, and a payment-confirmed event. Document which system emits each event, whether a retry duplicates it, which identity can link steps, and which records are the source of truth. A click on an upgrade button is not a completed payment. Compare the resulting event counts with your application or payment records before calling a funnel a conversion rate.

PostHog’s product-analytics pricing documentation bills by captured event volume and currently lists the first one million events in its free allocation. This is an event allowance, not a monthly-active-user limit or a guarantee that every PostHog product is free. Estimate your own events per action and expected volume; check current plan rules and configuration before enabling capture. This article does not make a price or feature ranking against Mixpanel or Amplitude.

Session replay: inspect an interaction without assuming the cause

If aggregate events show a drop-off, a permitted replay may help identify a confusing screen or a failed interaction to investigate. Test the hypothesis against application errors, device behavior, support reports, and a subsequent measurement. Do not infer that watching a recording proves why someone left or that changing the screen increased paid signups.

PostHog’s web session-replay pricing lists a separate first-5,000-web-recordings-per-month free allocation; mobile recordings and product-analytics events have their own units. Recording volume, eligibility, capture settings, and any paid usage require a separate estimate.

Replay needs a data-handling decision before activation. PostHog’s privacy controls guide says inputs are masked by default but ordinary page text is not. Its network-recording guide says request/response bodies are off by default, and that enabled captures may require a site-specific masking function for sensitive payloads. Decide which pages and users may be recorded; inspect text, inputs, URLs, and network data in a test session; configure exclusions or masking; restrict access and retention; and have the deployment reviewed against its actual privacy and consent requirements. Defaults alone do not establish compliance.

Should you keep GA4?

If an existing GA4 setup answers the question and its reports or integrations fit your workflow, keeping it may avoid another integration and a discontinuity in historical reporting. Google’s reporting-surface comparison distinguishes reports, explorations, the API, and exports; it lists sampling as possible in reports and explorations and in the Data API under applicable event-quota conditions, while BigQuery export is marked unsampled in its comparison table. Its footnote describes an exploration event threshold; this does not mean that every GA4 number is sampled. Its modeled key-events guide explains that some attributed events can be modeled when direct observation is unavailable. An apparent mismatch with a database count calls for checking event definitions, attribution, filters, and the reporting surface—not a general verdict that GA4 is unusable.

When considering a new tool, run a defined comparison period alongside the existing setup. Compare like-for-like page and event definitions, document differences in collection and attribution, and test a real decision before removing the old instrumentation. No vendor’s dashboard should be assumed to match another vendor’s or a payment ledger without reconciliation.

A measurement and cost worksheet

  1. Decision: Write the product or editorial decision, such as whether to revise a signup step or a landing page.
  2. Definition: Specify the pageview, custom event, completed action, or replay evidence needed; identify the system of record.
  3. Volume: Estimate monthly pageviews plus custom events for traffic plans; captured events for product analytics; and web or mobile recordings separately for replay. Do not convert visitors or revenue directly into a vendor tier.
  4. Data controls: List the pages, fields, network payloads, identifiers, access roles, retention settings, and consent questions to review before deployment.
  5. Verification: Trigger test actions, compare the recorded results with first-party records, and inspect any replay for unintended data capture.
  6. Recheck: Consult each vendor’s current pricing, terms, and documentation when usage or configuration changes; budget for paid usage and operational work rather than treating a trial or free allocation as an indefinite total cost.

Bottom line: Choose the smallest measurement setup that answers a specific question with acceptable data handling. Plausible or Fathom may cover website reporting, PostHog may cover defined events or replay, and an existing GA4 implementation may already cover part of the task. A tool decision should follow a tested measurement definition—not a blanket instruction to replace GA4 or install every layer.

Feature Flag Tools for Solo Devs: LaunchDarkly vs Unleash vs PostHog · AI Analytics Tools: Mixpanel vs Amplitude vs June for Micro-SaaS · switch archive

Pin It on Pinterest